Google Secure Search spells the end of free search information
Posted by Richard Apps | Posted in Clients, Design, Government, SEO, User Experience | Posted on 26-05-2010
Tags: secure search
1
Google recently launched a secure version of google search. This blog post looks in a little more detail about what this means should they move to make secure search the default choice. Good news for users, bad news for webmasters.
This evening I spare a thought for our clients. In this atmosphere of frugality and prudence another thread of the rug under their feet is being tugged.
My day is increasingly spent in meetings and managing the minutiae of project and departmental needs. Amongst this juggling act, on occasion I have the opportunity to catch up on my arch nemesis ‘The Inbox’. Today there was a particularly intriguing line item that had me both troubled and perplexed. My colleague, Tom Newman, had sent me a one liner:
“Google launch HTTPS. We need to talk”.
My somewhat dismissive response was immediately
“OK so they add an ‘s’ to the protocol definition. Err… WHO CARES?”
I will not bore you with the rest of this thread. But for the technically minded I’ll give you a précis of what Tom then patiently related to me.
The web page you are reading was delivered to your computer through a type of computer language. The language used is defined by the first part of the web address. Ever wondered what the “http” bit of http://blog.wtg.co.uk stands for? It’s HyperText Transfer Protocol, computer scientists tend to swap the word ‘language’ for ‘protocol’ when they get computers talking to other computers (humans use language, animals communicate, and computers have protocols). The Hypertext bit is the a fancy word for ‘text with links in it’ (when Sir Tim Berners-Lee was busy inventing the internet, ‘Links’ were a new concept, ergo we got the word “Hypertext”). Thus HTTP describes what language your web browser will use to get the web page you are now viewing. When you request a page by clicking on a link, your browser usually lets the new web page you are visiting know where you’ve come from. This bit of information (the page address you were on before you clicked the link) is called ‘the referrer’ and although you never get to see it, it is tremendously useful to the web site you are visiting.
“Why?” I hear you ask. Well, let’s put ourselves in the shoes of the hypothetical online retailer, richardsbetterbargains.com. Richard is new to the retail business and as he doesn’t have a high street presence how does he know what his customers are looking for? The realistic options for Richard are:
- He could wait until he’s identified patterns from his sales orders. This could take months, plus, if an item is out of stock he won’t register the sale and so will never get a proper grasp on the demand for a particular item.
- He could commission a market researcher to find out what people really want by standing in the street and asking them. Unfortunately the man in the street is there because he’s not sitting at home spending vast quantities of hard earned cash online. The man on the street is not Richards target audience, the man on the street is buying something else.
- He could run a ‘referrers report’ that tells him which search engine his potential customers came from and what they were searching for. This is much more promising. Being the smart chap he is Richard could then stock more of widget X, thus increasing his sales many times over. Possibly he could even run a highly successful keywords campaign therfore generating the revenue that allows him to retire to the desert island paradise of his choice.
A referrers report is therefore a useful thing. Its usefulness is not just limited to online retail. Finding out where people have just come from or what they are looking for allows web designers the opportunity to optimise pages and navigation schemes to fulfil these user goals. Giving users what they are looking for can increase conversion, enhance usability or potentially improve that all important key metric for the resident webmaster.
So now we add the letter ‘s’. Instead of http://www.google.com, the URL of the worlds favourite search engine is now https://www.google.com. The mysterious ‘s’ stands for “Secure”. This means that as well as making sure that your page is encrypted (thus can’t be read by anyone else), it also blocks the useful referrer information. Suddenly all those lovely reports about where your site visitors come from and the search terms they use aren’t reliable or possibly even usable anymore.
So what happens to poor old richardsbetterbargains.com?
It is a stark choice, without a reliable referrers report poor old Richard doesn’t know what his customers are looking for anymore. Those stock lines that were previously flying off the shelves begin to stagnate and Richard is unable to replace them with in demand products. In desperation Richard turns to the market researchers who charge him a small fortune for ‘research of an unknown providence’. Sales continue to falter. Market opportunities are lost, by the time Richard is able to identify a successful product line from sales, those fickle customers have already moved on. Richardsbetterbargains.com eventually drifts away to .com heaven. Richard drifts back to designing interfaces to pay the mortgage on that pesky desert island paradise.
But WTG does a lot of work with central and local government. Why do they care if Google launches a secure search?… Good question.
When we’re designing an interface we use a user centred design approach. We want to know about the end user, who they are, what technology do they use, what websites do they visit, are there any groupings of users, why are they visiting the site, what are they looking for? You can see where this is going. One of the first and most useful sources of data commonly available to us is a referrers report – specifically the search terms used by customers trying to obtain goods or services is particularly useful. This report is a gold mine. With some basic analysis it is possible to infer many nuggets that guide and inform the information architecture and content strategy of a website. But the beauty of the referrers report is that it is easy to obtain (straight web logs) and there are many simple analysis tools available, i.e. it is a cheap, reliable (but not necessarily authoritative) source of information. Sure, the information can be obtained from other sources but there is a price tag associated.
This is why I spare a thought for our clients. In this time of budget cuts and tightened purse strings, efficiency through technological innovation is oft touted as the route to salvation. But if Google’s secure search takes off, how many cash strapped government departments are going to invest the time and money to find out where their customers come from and what they searched for?
If you are thinking about your web offering or if you want to know a bit more about what WTG can do for your organisation get in touch.




